Skip the skillet and fire up the air fryer for an Air Fryer Grilled Cheese recipe that sandwiches your cheeses of choice in a hot and toasty bread pocket.
Sandwich the cheese slices between the two pieces of bread.
Butter both sides of the sandwich then place it inside the air fryer basket.
Air-fry the sandwich at 360°F until golden brown and crispy, 5 to 7 minutes. Remove and let cool slightly then serve.
Kelly's Note:
Keep the crusts on or go my homemade Uncrustables route by stamping out the sandwich with a cookie cutter and sealing the edges shut. Check out the link to my favorite Uncrustables cookie cutter above!