One day. Three bakeries. Five miles. Nine doughnuts. Welcome to The Just a Taste Doughnuthon.
I know what you’re thinking, “This girl needs to get a life.” But I’ve lived in New York City for almost two years now, and I still have yet to find a jaw-dropping, fancily frosted, circuitous ‘nut-o-perfection that leaves an impression lasting longer than the glaze on my fingers. And have I mentioned that doughnuts are my favorite food group?
Here were the rules:
- I compiled a list of bakeries based on previous rankings and my own curiosity and understanding of New York City’s doughnut scene.
- I had to buy the three most popular doughnuts from each bakery, based on the recommendation of the person taking my order.
- I had to speed-walk (Are you getting the visual here? Feel free to laugh at/with me) from one doughnut spot to the next, hence the marathon aspect of my adventure.
Fast forward to this morning. Camera and reporter’s notebook in hand, I made my way from my apartment to The Donut Pub for the first stop on my Tour de Glaze. I arrived at a quiet storefront and quickly learned that the historic spot, founded in 1964, is most frequented for its Boston Kreme, jelly and Honey Dip doughnuts. I took a seat at the counter and started tasting. The Boston Kreme was filled with vanilla-favored cream and finished with chocolate glaze. Relatively nondescript, but enjoyable nonetheless. The jelly doughnut proved to be my least favorite of the stop, as it gushed with overly sweetened preservatives. I topped off my sugar high with a bite of the Honey Dip, which was a standard glazed doughnut that was both airy and moist. Satisfied, I packed up and moved onward to checkpoint number two …
Balthazar Bakery is located in the heart of the West Village, adjacent to its sister shop, Balthazar Restaurant. I made my way inside the tiny store to find a mass of New Yorkers eager to make their early morning bread buys. Again, I requested one of each of the three most popular doughnuts, which were the pistachio-topped, the chocolate and the cinnamon-sugar. I bit into the pistachio doughnut and my taste-buds were met with the perfect balance of savory and sweet flavors while the exterior popped with bright green visual appeal. Next up was the chocolate, which I can only describe as a heavenly marriage between brownie batter and ganache glaze. My stop ended with a bite of the cinnamon-sugar doughnut. It was basic and relatively bland in flavor, especially compared to the two stand-outs it was up against. More than half-way through my quest for glazed glory, I packed up and began the trek to what many consider the holy grail of deep-fried dough …
Two words: Doughnut Plant. It’s enough to make any doughnut-lover weak in the knees (and stomach). The Doughnut Plant is likely the most famous doughnut shop in all of New York City. From an epic battle on Throwdown with Bobby Flay, to recently being named one of the Top 10 Best Places for Doughnuts (in America) by Bon Appetit, I was curious to see if this place could live up to the hype. I placed my order for one of each of their Crème Brûlée, Coconut and Tres Leches doughnuts and then got comfortable at a nearby park bench. One bite of the Crème Brûlée doughnut and I was sold. What begins as a taste of perfectly torched sugar exterior ends with a whirl of delicate custard piped inside a light and airy dough. It was the perfect size, the perfect shape, the perfect everything. I should’ve known it wasn’t going to be topped. The coconut and Tres Leches seemed like after thoughts as I stared down the remainder of my first and favorite pick. While massive in size, the square-shaped coconut-filled doughnut just didn’t do much for me. The Tres Leches also left much to the imagination as it crumbled with minimum moisture.
In all, I had just a taste of nine different doughnuts in just under two hours while covering more than 5.2 miles of New York City turf. I know you’re now waiting on pins and sprinkles for the results, and so without further ado, The 2010 Just a Taste Doughnuthon results are …
Best Topping – Balthazar Bakery’s Pistachio Doughnut
Best Filling – The Doughnut Plant’s Crème Brûlée Doughnut
Most Decadent – Balthazar Bakery’s Chocolate Doughnut
Best Basic – The Donut Pub’s Honey Dip Doughnut
Most Original – The Doughnut Plant’s Tres Leches Doughnut
Best Overall – The Doughnut Plant’s Crème Brûlée Doughnut
This post may contain affiliate links.
THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU. OMG. I have not been able to stop searching and looking at your recipes. So much inspiration , when I feel I need to try something new. I love the way you make the recipes so you can increase the qty, I am not tech savvy and cant wait to get into my kitchen to try your recipes. I look for food items to feed many at events I hold, and nice and fancy but wont cost the earth or take all day to cook. I cannot thank you enough for changing this old boring cooks life.
I’m so glad you’ve been enjoying Just a Taste, Karen!
Hi there,
Get on the subway and go to Franklin ave in Brooklyn to try Dough. It was my favorite when I lived there. As good as the Doughnut Plant!
Yes! I love Dough!
Love this!
I love this article! I love baking and cooking and every time I visit a new place I always start with finding the best bakeries to eat delicious food.
If I got to New York, I’m adding Balthazar Bakery and Donut Plant on my list of places to go.
Thank you so much, Sachika!
You need to come to Kailua kona, hi and try Holy Donuts :D best donuts ever!
Would love to try them!
Ah! You couldn’t have posted a link to this at a better time. I’ll be in Manhattan tomorrow and Friday and was looking for more food places to go to! I love Doughnut Plant but want to try some new places!
If you ever find yourself in San Francisco (and in need of a donut) please, please, please do yourself a favor and stop at Dynamo Donuts. It’s a little shop that can easily go unnoticed, but man oh man…talk about YUM! It’s definitely worth the trip.
…but I really WANT that Creme Brulee Doughnut…
Have you ever tried Rose’s Doughnuts on Linda Vista at Napa in San Diego, by USD?
Buttermilk Bars to break a diet over… Mmmm…
Wow those all look amazing! I would totally join you on the second donut-a-thon!
i haven’t had a doughnut in ages, though when i was a kid my dad would pile my sister and me into his blue toyota pick-up every sunday morning for the drive down rt. 9 to dunkin donuts (we left my mother happily at home).
but oh man, kell, this post made me want one! specifically, it made me want one of those chocolate donuts… and one of those pistachio-encrusted ones, too. they look de-lish.
It is 9:00 p.m. in LA and I am ever craving a doughnut, THE DOUGHNUT, after reading your post.
Next time I am in NY I , too, will make the doughnut trek. Thank you for forging the trail!
A fan,
Noma